Production Builder Showdown · Boise Area

Production Builder
Showdown

The ten builders that sell most of the new homes in the Treasure Valley, side by side. Base prices, sales volume, what is actually standard, warranties, this month's incentives, and who each one is best for.

Book a discovery callI'll tell you which two builders fit your budget and timeline
10Builders compared
$345KLowest base price
29%Of ranked sales are CBH
7–10Months to build
Price and volume

Where each builder lands on price, and how many homes they sell

CBH sells about twice as many homes as Toll, the number two builder. Toll covers the widest price spread. KB and Hayden have the lowest entry prices, mostly in Canyon County.

Base price range and 2026 homes sold for 10 Boise-area production builders

Base "from" prices from builder websites and new home listing sites, October 2026. Upgrades and lot premiums usually add 10% to 15%. Homes sold from BuildIdaho's 2026 Top Builders ranking for the Boise area. Shea is not in that ranking. Brighton does not publish base prices, so its range is current available homes.

The scorecard

Ten builders, one table

How you buy, how much you can personalize, what the builder puts in writing, and what comes included. Scroll sideways on a phone.

BuilderBase priceHow you buyPersonalizingWarranty in writingWorth knowing
CBH Homes$374K–$695KSpec homes onlyPick a finish paletteNot publishedIdaho's largest builder. Gutters only where code requires and pressboard siding keep prices down.
Lennar$378K–$601KMostly quick move-insMinimal; features pre-selected1-2-10Everything's Included: fridge, fencing, tankless water heater, smart thermostat. Next Gen plan adds a private suite.
Hayden Homes$345K–$500KSpecs or pick plan and lotPlan and lot choiceNot publishedThird-party plus 300-point inspection. Plans from about 1,024 sq ft. Simplicity line builds on your land.
Hubble Homes$354K–$558KSpecs or buildPlan options and design centerNot publishedDovetail soft-close drawers and full gutters standard. HERS-rated, ENERGY STAR homes. Merging with Richmond American under one parent.
KB Home$345K–$408KBuilt to orderPlan, elevation, lot, design studio1-2-10Every home designed to be ENERGY STAR certified. Western valley only: Caldwell, Nampa, Kuna, Meridian.
Toll Brothers$387K–$915KSpecs or semi-custom buildMost structural options of the groupNot publishedHardie siding, ZIP System, full fencing. Pools in every community. RV garages. 55+ at Regency.
Richmond American$468K–$750KSpecs or buildStructural options and design galleryNot publishedBasements and attached RV garages on select plans. Same parent company as Hubble.
Shea Homes$357K–$695KSpecs or buildCurated DesignJoy packagesVisits at 1, 5, 11 moValnova and Trilogy Valor (55+ golf). Smart home, landscaping, and fencing included at Valnova.
Blackrock Homes$395K–$465KSpecs or buildTiered finish collectionsNot publishedLocal since the late 1980s. Single-level living focus, all in Meridian. Highest median price per sq ft of the group.
Brighton Homes$445K–$860KTurnkey specs and pre-salesLimited; turnkey by designNot publishedMulti Gen homes with private entry, kitchenette, and bath. Landscaping and fencing on listings. 2025 IBR Best Homebuilder.

From builder websites, BuildIdaho, and my own tours, October 2026. "Not published" means the builder offers a warranty but does not post the terms online. Ask for the warranty document before you sign.

What's actually standard

Three builders, same size house, very different box

I toured a roughly 2,000 sq ft home from CBH, Hubble, and Toll in Meridian. The price gap is about $70K. Here is where it goes.

CBH HomesHubble HomesToll Brothers
Price as touredAbout $480K$520K–$570KAbout $550K
GuttersOnly where code requiresFull guttersFull, routed underground
Siding and sheathingPressboard sidingNot noted on tourHardie siding and ZIP System
Crawl spaceVentedConditionedVented
Drawer boxesSoft-close varies by homeSolid wood, dovetailed, soft-closeMelamine, not soft-close
Ceilings8 ft8 ft (9 ft in elevated series)9 ft
Countertops2 cm quartz kitchen, laminate in secondary bathsGranite throughout3 cm quartz kitchen, solid surface baths
Primary showerFiberglassFiberglass (tile is an upgrade)Tiled to the ceiling
FireplaceMaybe, varies by planUpgradeUpgrade, about $6K–$7K
Backyard on a buildSpec only, not installedNone on builds; grass and gravel on specsDirt on builds; sod and sprinklers on specs
Community amenitiesWalking pathsVariesPool in every community
Build timeSpec homes only7–8 months8–10 months

LennarEverything-included promos add real value at the price. Plan on a thorough third-party inspection, because punch lists tend to run long.

HaydenSimilar product to Hubble with fewer quality complaints than most entry builders. Plans top out near 3,000 sq ft, and builds run 7 to 8 months.

Every builderWater in the crawl space is the most common issue I see across builders at every price point. Check grading and drainage at your pre-drywall and final walks.

From my "I Visited 3 Boise Builders" tour and "New Construction in Boise" video, fall 2026. Standards change by community and product line, so confirm each item on the specific home.

This month's incentives

What builders are advertising in October 2026

Advertised incentives are the starting point. Most are tied to the builder's preferred lender, and the best numbers land on finished spec homes the builder wants off the books.

BuilderAdvertised offerCatch
CBH Homes4.25% rate through a 2/1 temporary buydown, plus appliances or a $3,000 creditFHA with 3.5% down, contracts dated Oct 1–31. Rate steps up after two years.
Hubble HomesRates from 4.999% on 30-year FHA; up to $40K Flex FundsFlex Funds on select quick move-ins only
Hayden Homes4.99% fixed at Harvest Creek; up to $25K savings at Huntington RidgeCommunity-specific
Shea HomesQuick move-in incentives of about $2,800 to $26,500 at ValnovaVaries by home
Brighton Homes$15,000 toward closing costs or rate buydown on a listed Arbor homeSingle listing
LennarRate buydowns and closing cost help on select homesThrough Lennar Mortgage
Recent client result

Double the builder's original incentive

I recently doubled a client's incentive by putting competing builders against each other. The advertised number is where negotiation starts. A sales rep who only sells one community can't run that play for you.

From builder websites and listings, October 2026. Offers change monthly and some end with the month. Ask me for this month's numbers before you tour.

Best for

Which builder fits which buyer

There is no best builder, only the best fit for your budget, timeline, and what you care about inside the walls.

Lowest entry price

KB Home and Hayden

Base prices start near $345K in Caldwell and Nampa. KB builds to order with ENERGY STAR homes; Hayden offers the smallest plans.

Most included at the price

Lennar

Fridge, fencing, tankless water heater, and smart thermostat with no upgrade packages to price out.

Quality for the money

Hubble Homes

Dovetail drawers, full gutters, and a conditioned crawl space on the one I owned. Good long-term rental and family homes.

Fastest, lowest price

CBH Homes

Spec homes ready in 30 to 45 days when finished, at the lowest price per foot in many communities. Budget for gutters and a backyard.

Amenities and RV garages

Toll Brothers

Pools in every community, RV and boat garages, Hardie siding, and the most structural options. Torrente in Eagle is the standout.

Basements

Richmond American

One of the few production builders offering basements and attached RV garages on select plans.

55+ living

Shea Trilogy and Toll Regency

Trilogy Valor in Kuna has golf, a resort club, and a restaurant. Toll's Regency at Milestone Ranch is in Star.

Multigenerational

Brighton and Lennar

Brighton's Multi Gen homes and Lennar's Next Gen plan both add a private suite with its own entry and kitchenette.

Single-level in Meridian

Blackrock Homes

A local builder focused on single-level plans, with a gated estates section at Skybreak.

Before you sign

10 questions to ask every production builder

The answers change the real price of the house. Most buyers never ask.

  1. 1
    Are gutters on the whole house?Some builders only gutter what code requires, and roof runoff ruins pressboard siding over time.
  2. 2
    Is the crawl space vented or conditioned?Conditioned means warmer floors, better efficiency, and fewer critters.
  3. 3
    What are the drawer boxes made of?Dovetail joints last. Stapled melamine falls apart. I check drawers on every tour.
  4. 4
    What comes in the backyard?Many builds are delivered as dirt. Fencing, sod, and a patio can run thousands.
  5. 5
    How much is the earnest money, and is there a promissory note?Earnest money runs 2% to 10%. Some builders add a note on top that they can enforce if you walk.
  6. 6
    What percent of upgrades is due at selection?25%, 50%, or 100% of your design choices can be due up front.
  7. 7
    How much of the incentive requires your lender?Often part of it works with any lender and part only with theirs. Get pre-approved elsewhere for leverage.
  8. 8
    Is there a real financing or home-sale contingency?Most builders keep your deposit if you can't close. Know that before you sign.
  9. 9
    Can I get the warranty document now?Most builders here offer one but don't post the terms. Read it before you commit.
  10. 10
    What is the realistic build time?I have never seen a production home finished in 6 months. Plan on 7 to 10, longer where permits are slow.
Next step

Let builders compete for you

I work with all ten of these builders, so I have no reason to steer you to one. The builder pays my commission, so having me on your side costs you nothing. Text me before you tour so I can register you, then I'll put the incentives side by side.

Curtis Chism · REALTOR® SP56593 · eXp Realty
Living in Boise Idaho · 208-510-0427

Book a discovery call See all 39 builders

Watching on YouTube? Comment SHOWDOWN and I'll send this guide plus this month's incentive list.

Prices, standard features, warranties, and incentives change often. Figures reflect October 2026 and come from builder websites, new home listing sites, BuildIdaho, and my own tours. Builder descriptions summarize each builder's own published claims. Verify current details with me and the builder before making decisions. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.